Information message No. 11
Professional public organizations NABAUz and PAU express their gratitude for your support and assistance in the development of auditing activity. At present we are facing a number of inconsistencies and contradictions in regulatory documents, which significantly affect the process of selection of audit organizations to conduct audits of enterprises with state share of more than 50%.
We ask you to familiarize yourself with the following problems and proposals for their solution:
- Contradictions in the requirements of the Public Procurement Law and other laws:
– According to ZRU-684 “On Public Procurement”, companies-customers with state share are obliged to place announcements on the state procurement portal. Potential performers submit their bids through this portal, becoming participants in the selection process.
– At the same time, according to the Law on Joint Stock Companies and the Law on Limited and Additional Liability Companies, the procedure for selecting an audit organization does not require the use of the public procurement portal, which creates contradictions.
- Inconsistency of selection procedures and ISA requirements:
– According to ISA-200 and ISA-210, audit organizations are required to conduct preliminary procedures to assess the client and audit risk before concluding a contract.
– The Public Procurement Law prohibits any contact between the auditor and the client before the selection is finalized, which makes it difficult to comply with ISA requirements.
3 Lack of formalized systems for assessing the quality of services:
– The Public Procurement Law requires that a quality indicator be taken into account when selecting a contractor, but does not provide unambiguous criteria for assessing the quality of services at the procurement stage. This leads to the formal application of this requirement.
4 The use of the term “work” in the Public Procurement Law:
– The term “work” is used in the law despite its exclusion from reporting documents by the new version of the Tax Code.
In connection with the above-mentioned shortcomings and contradictions, we ask you to consider the possibility of amending the PPA “On Public Procurement”. Our proposals on certain issues are given in the annexes to this letter. We count on your understanding and support in addressing these issues to improve and simplify the procedures for selecting audit organizations. Thank you for your attention and participation.
Sincerely, Chamber of Auditors of Uzbekistan